MotherDuck/DuckDB as a cost-effective data warehouse
In the past, the adoption of data warehousing solutions by small businesses has been hampered by several significant challenges. The complexity associated with the setup, configuration, and ongoing maintainance of these traditional solutions can present a formidable barrier, particularly for small teams operating with limited resources and budget. Modern cloud-based solutions have democratized access to these powerful capabilities, eliminating the need for significant upfront capital expenditure on infrastructure and offering flexible, pay-as-you-go pricing models that align more closely with the budget constraints of SMBs.
MotherDuck is a new emerging solution of this kind in the data warehousing market. It is positioned as a cost-effective data warehouse, particularly well-suited for small businesses and teams whose data analysis requirements fall within the realm of "small to medium data". Built on the top of the open-source DuckDB engine, MotherDuck inherits its performance and lightweight nature. By integrating local DuckDB with cloud MotherDuck, you can achieve ultra-lightweight data consolidation and transformation pipelines with minimal tool costs.
What is missed here? While data engineers can do all they need in brilliant MotherDuck/DuckDB UI, all other users still need a business intelligence tool to access MotherDuck for making data-driven decisions. BI tools provide user-friendly interfaces that allow users without deep technical skills (without SQL knowledge) to explore and analyze data. Here is a comparison of BI tools that can use MotherDuck as a data source in terms of pricing and capabilities (only products with open/known pricing are included):
MotherDuck BI tools comparison
Product | Price | Pros | Cons |
---|---|---|---|
Metabase |
On-prem: free (community version)
|
Good for data exploration with web-based reports builder for non-technical users and basic dashboards. Self-hosted version is free/open source. |
Cloud Metabase does NOT support DuckDB /MotherDuck driver yet. Self-hosted Metabase requires installation of Metabase DuckDB driver. Default Metabase docker image is NOT compatible with DuckDB driver, you need to prepare own Debian-based docker image instead. |
Preset.io Apache Superset in cloud |
Cloud/up to 5 users: free
On-prem: free (Superset)
Cloud: $20/user/mo
|
A no-code interface for building charts quickly. Web-based SQL Editor for advanced querying. Choose it if you need to build charts and interactive dashboards to track KPIs and metrics. |
Some features, you can't really expect non-technical users to be able to intuitively utilize.
Not the best for data exploration / self-service reporting.
Self-hosted Superset requires installation of extra Python package (the DuckDB SQLAlchemy driver). |
SeekTable |
Cloud/personal: free
Cloud/sharing: $29/team/mo
On-prem: from $67/mo
|
Very good for tabular reports, especially pivot tables. Supports row-level security,
can utilize all power of DuckDB SQL dialect.
DuckDB connector (built-in) is available only in self-hosted SeekTable,
MotherDuck connector is available in cloud SeekTable for free users.
Especially cost effective when you need to share reports with many external viewers, offer self-service data exploration/reports sharing for non-IT users. |
Dashboards creation require basic HTML skills (no drag&drop UI designer) and available only in on-prem version. Only basic types of charts. |
PowerBI Desktop |
Personal: free
Pro: $14/user/mo
|
Enterprise-grade comprehensive BI solution. Good for one-time / manually created dashboards, however only detached (based on imported data) dashboards can be published/shared. |
Installation of DuckDB ODBC driver is required. MotherDuck is not supported in cloud PowerBI, you need to import data via PowerBI desktop (manually) or configure custom on-premises data gateway for automated refreshes. |
Hashboard |
Starter: $30/user/mo
min 2 users = $60/mo
|
Good for data exploration, automated insights. | Built for engineers (code-based business intelligence). |
Tableau Desktop |
Creator: $75/user/mo
Explorer: $42/user/mo
|
Professional BI tool for data exploration, reporting and dashboards. |
Installation of DuckDB JDBC driver is required. MotherDuck is not supported in cloud Tableau, you need to use self-hosted Tableau Server for reports sharing. |